West Orange Council Seat Opens When Joyce Rudin Becomes Mayor. Here's How It Gets Filled

Joyce Rudin's mayoral win leaves her West Orange council seat open in January. The new council gets 30 days to fill it, and the rest of the term goes on the November 2027 ballot.

JerseyTalks Staff3 min read11 views
File photo of the West Orange Municipal Building, a brick township hall, on a sunny day.

What happened

Joyce Rudin's mayoral win leaves her West Orange council seat open in January. The new council gets 30 days to fill it, and the rest of the term goes on the November 2027 ballot.

Where it happened

  • West Orange, Essex County.

Joyce Rudin's win in the West Orange mayor's race settled one question. It also opened another: who takes the township council seat she's about to leave behind?

Rudin finished first in the seven-way race for mayor on Nov. 3 with 5,854 votes, according to unofficial results from the Essex County Clerk's Office. In the council race, Jackie Hendy and Justin Goldsman took the top two spots. None of the results have been certified yet, and the totals can still shift as remaining ballots are counted.

Once Rudin is sworn in as mayor in January, her council seat goes empty, and voters won't be the ones filling it, at least not right away. Rudin said the four council members serving in January, including the two newcomers, will choose the replacement, and her own role will be limited to breaking a tie. "Ultimately, this is a decision for the new council to make, not the current council," she said.

At least one candidate wants the job. Kenneth Gibbons, who finished third in the council race with 5,894 unofficial votes, said he is interested and would be honored to be considered. "Almost 6,000 West Orange residents voted for me on November 3," he said. "The decision belongs to the council, and I believe they should hear from those voters before filling the seat."

Tammy Williams, who finished second in the mayor's race, laid out the rules, which she said the township clerk's office confirmed. The new council has 30 days after its Jan. 1 swearing-in to decide whether to fill the seat at all. It can appoint someone directly by majority vote, or collect resumes and hold interviews first. A 2-2 tie lets the mayor cast the deciding vote, but a 2-1 vote with one abstention fails, and the mayor can't step in. If no one wins a majority within 30 days, the seat stays empty. Either way, Williams said, the rest of the term goes on the November 2027 ballot, with no special election. She cited the state's Municipal Vacancy Law, N.J.S.A. 40A:16-5 and 40A:16-12.

First comes certification of the Nov. 3 results. Then the new council is sworn in on Jan. 1, and the 30-day clock starts. Whoever lands the seat, or doesn't, West Orange voters get the final word in November 2027.

Source: Essex County Clerk's Office unofficial results; statements from Joyce Rudin, Tammy Williams and Kenneth Gibbons.

File photo: West Orange Municipal Building. Jim.henderson / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

politicslocal governmentelectionswest orangeessex countyjoyce rudinwest orange town councilkenneth gibbonstammy williamscouncil vacancy2026 election
Filed under: Essex CountyMore from: West Orange